Carrot and Stick – An Avoidable Curse

“You need to put pressure on the team members, keep them on edge of their seat. Only then they will deliver to their full potential” 

I was startled to hear those words from my Supervisor. It was in complete contradiction to the school of thoughts I believed in. Coming from a senior member in the side, it was quite hard to believe that such old habits hadn’t died a natural death.

I have been a huge fan of “The Drive” by Daniel Pink and the discussion I would like to unfold in this article is inspired by the same.

Carrot and Stick, or the philosophy my Supervisor believed in revolves around a simple theory – as an employee, if you worked extremely hard, you get bonus or incentives, otherwise, there is a pink slip waiting for you at the desk the next day. It is a good concept in theory and works pretty well for problems that are mechanical or algorithmic in nature and require to accomplish a predefined number of steps to resolve it. However, the moment the tasks turn into one that require cognitive skills, creativity and decision making, Carrot and Stick falls flat on face.

Consider the example of a Pizza Delivery boy. If his manager were to give him incentives based on the number of Pizza he is able to deliver, it would definitely push him to do better. Or for a Call Center Support, the incentives pr pressure associated with ‘Number of Calls’ can be a driving factor. Such kind of external motivation factors can work in this scenario as there is hardly any creativity involved to crush.

But if the same external motivation is applied to an artist, over a period of time, carrot and sticks could achieve exactly opposite. The external factors would drive the artist to think of his canvas as a task rather than a chance to showcase his mastery, thereby pushing him to shortcuts, compromises on quality of his work and making his passion mundane.  His intrinsic motivation would decline over time, diminishing his creativity and quality.

This applies to field of Software Development as well, which to me, is a craft rather than an algorithmic job. If the focus is on quantity than on quality, it wouldn’t need Nostradamus to predict where the Software is heading to. Unwanted pressure and avoidable performance measurement metrics could lead to Employee frustrations , low performance and eventual high attrition rates.

One might ask – Can intrinsic motivation make such a huge impact ? One of the finest example of people working for passion is Wikipedia. Way back in late nineties, Microsoft started the initiative of bring up the digital encyclopedia. They had engaged the best of minds, specialists from all the domains but the initiative couldn’t get anywhere near the success which a group of unrelated, unpaid volunteers managed to do with Wikipedia. What drove them was their passion for mastering their skills without someone chaining their intrinsic technical eagerness.

That doesn’t mean monetary benefits aren’t important, especially in an organization. If the employee isn’t paid well, his focus would be on unfairness of the situation rather the task he is supposed to accomplish. But once we are passed that threshold, it is the intrinsic motivation that has to encouraged.

Quite sadly, that is something which some organizations and managers do not still appreciate or acknowledge. However, if they were to still stick to old schools of thoughts, it might not be far, before they find themselves in their own “well dug” graves. It is high time the managers discard pursuit for statically measuring performance and considering factors such as “facetime” as the de-facto measurement of commitment and productivity. Such metrics along with approaches like Carrot and Sticks could only breed employee frustrations and low performances.

Instead, they should focus on fostering 3 important factors,Autonomy, Mastery and Purpose, which could bring the best out of the employees by instilling confidence and responsibility in them. It makes them feel valued, take ownership of their work and encourages them to perform better.

The role of Scrum Master in a Scrum is many ways the ideal leadership methodology in today’s high pressure competitive world. As a Manager, it is your responsibility to hire the best for job, but once your hire them, trust them completely. From that point, your duty is to server as the “servant leader” of the group, removing the impediments (technical,non-technical) that the team faces, and ensure that they are in right spirits when at their desk, so that they would deliver the best for you. 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s